A plaque remaining from the Big Apple Night Club at West 135th Street and Seventh Avenue in Harlem.

Above, a 1934 plaque from the Big Apple Night Club at West 135th Street and Seventh Avenue in Harlem. Discarded as trash in 2006. Now a Popeyes fast food restaurant on Google Maps.

Recent entries:
Entry in progress—BP (8/16)
“The federal government is organized crime” (8/16)
“A crow walks into a bar, and he says ‘ouch’. It was a crow bar” (bar joke) (8/16)
“A crow walks into a bar. It becomes a crowbar” (bar joke) (8/16)
“True fact: Before the crowbar was invented, most crows drank at home” (8/16)
More new entries...

A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z


Entry from October 03, 2021
“All my life I have called it a cookie sheet and today I heard someone call it a cooking sheet”

Is it called a cookie sheet or a cooking sheet?

“‘@abbiemedcalf: Do you say cookie sheet? Or cooking sheet lol’ I say cookies? Shit” was posted on Twitter by MilwaukeeMade on March 11, 2013. “I literally just stopped everything and go ‘wait. Serious question.... is it called a cookie sheet… or a cooking sheet...?’” was posted on Twitter by madz on December 8, 2016. “Am I crazy, or is it called a ‘cookie sheet’, not a ‘cooking sheet’...or have I been wrong MY WHOLE LIFE???” was posted on Twitter by Erin Carlson, PhD on December 8, 2018.

“All my life I have called it a cookie sheet and today I heard someone call it a cooking sheet. I’m questioning my whole life now” was posted on Twitter by “T” on September 29, 2020, and this became a meme. “I’ve never heard anyone who cooks or bakes for a living call it a ‘cooking sheet’. It’s a cookie sheet, or a baking sheet, or a sheet pan, or a baking pan” is a reply that was posted on Twitter by toferj on September 30, 2020.


Wikipedia: Sheet pan
A sheet pan, baking tray or baking sheet is a flat, rectangular metal pan used in an oven. It is often used for baking bread rolls, pastries and flat products such as cookies, sheet cakes, Swiss rolls and pizzas.
(...)
Types and sizes
A sheet pan that has a continuous lip around all four sides may be called a jelly roll pan. A pan that has at least one side flat, so that it is easy to slide the baked product off the end, may be called a cookie sheet.

Twitter
Essential Cassandra@buybk·Jan 5, 2012
Replying to @smexybooks
@smexybooks @FictionVxn I thought a cooking sheet was a big ol flat piece of metal --as in cookie sheet

Twitter
MilwaukeeMade
@nate_millie
“@abbiemedcalf: Do you say cookie sheet? Or cooking sheet lol” I say cookies? Shit.
5:41 PM · Mar 11, 2013·Twitter for Android

Twitter
madz
@maddiesuxxx
I literally just stopped everything and go “wait. Serious question.... is it called a cookie sheet… or a cooking sheet...?”
5:04 AM · Dec 8, 2016·Twitter for iPhone

Twitter
Erin Carlson, PhD
@ErinRCPhD
Replying to @SeanLowe09
Am I crazy, or is it called a “cookie sheet”, not a “cooking sheet”...or have I been wrong MY WHOLE LIFE???
8:22 PM · Dec 8, 2018·Twitter for iPhone

Twitter
Lisa
@AhLisaNoEnCasa
Replying to @SeanLowe09
The only error here is calling a ‘cookie’ sheet a ‘cooking’ sheet.
7:30 AM · Dec 9, 2018·Twitter for Android

Twitter
Bethany Stevenson
@HeyMsStevenson
Replying to @alfiekohn
That it’s a COOKING sheet, not a COOKIE sheet. (But, to be fair, my mom used them almost exclusively for making cookies.)
1:34 PM · Jul 28, 2019·Twitter for Android

Twitter
T
@Tlapp1
All my life I have called it a cookie sheet and today I heard someone call it a cooking sheet. I’m questioning my whole life now.
What do you call it?
7:54 AM · Sep 29, 2020·Twitter for Android

Twitter
AgingWino
@AgingWino
Replying to @Tlapp1
Cookie sheet, cookie tray, cooking sheet, baking tray, baking sheet, sheet pan. I think my lack of commitment comes from 10-15 years of recipes from different times/places. And I’ve been catering for 5 years with women 25-82 and they all have a different word for it.
7:21 PM · Sep 29, 2020·Twitter for Android

Twitter
Marie without the M
@wyldstatic
Replying to @Tlapp1
Cookie sheet or alternately baking sheeting. Cooking sheet?? Never
8:52 PM · Sep 29, 2020·Twitter for iPhone

Twitter
Influence
@hiddenpost_its
Cookie sheet, cooking sheet, or baking sheet?
Quote Tweet
T
@Tlapp1
· Sep 29, 2020
All my life I have called it a cookie sheet and today I heard someone call it a cooking sheet. I’m questioning my whole life now.
What do you call it?
11:28 PM · Sep 29, 2020 from Toronto, Ontario·Twitter for iPhone

Twitter
toferj
@toferj_
Replying to @Tlapp1
I’ve never heard anyone who cooks or bakes for a living call it a “cooking sheet”. It’s a cookie sheet, or a baking sheet, or a sheet pan, or a baking pan.
3:51 AM · Sep 30, 2020·Twitter for Android

Facebook
Z88.3, Orlando FL
December 4, 2020 at 2:27 PM ·
Now that we’re in Christmas treats season, it’s time to weigh in- is it cookie or cooking sheet? 🤔
(The following text is shown on an image.—ed.)
ALL MY LIFE I’VE CALLED IT
A COOKIE SHEET
AND TODAY I HEARD
SOMEONE CALL IT
A COOKING SHEET.
I’M QUESTIONING MY
WHOLE LIFE NOW.

Twitter
Hayden Noel
@noelhayd
It is NOT cooking sheet. Try and find a “cooking” sheet on google and it will say baking/cookie sheet. You don’t “cook” on that sheet you “bake”.
@ScottyGZone @975Hans
2:44 PM · Feb 12, 2021·Twitter Web App

Twitter
That Mom Tho
@mom_tho
saw someone asking about using a cooking sheet but I always thought it was cookie sheet and wtf
6:02 PM · Mar 5, 2021·Twitter for iPhone

Twitter
Vanessa
@NerdyNessa88
I saw a post on Facebook “all my life I’ve called it a cookie sheet, but it’s really a cooking sheet”...well I Googled “cooking sheet” and Google asked me if I meant cookie sheet. It’s cookie sheet...right?...right?
7:51 PM · Jul 16, 2021·Twitter for Android

Twitter
Americana Mama
@AmericanaMama_
All my life I have been calling it a cookie sheet and today I heard someone call it a cooking sheet. I’m questioning my whole life now.
1:34 AM · Jul 20, 2021·Twitter for Android

Facebook
MY CRAZY WORLD
October 4, 2021 at 7:16 AM ·
All my life I have called it a
cookie sheet and today I
heard someone call it a
cooking sheet. I’m
questioning my whole life
now. 

Posted by Barry Popik
New York CityFood/Drink • Sunday, October 03, 2021 • Permalink