“Pie Rates of the Caribbean”—a pun on the Pirates of the Caribbean film series—has been printed on many images. “Pie rates of the Caribbean.  Rubbish.  No pies” was posted on Twitter on December 27, 2008. “Due to a mix-up at Blockbusters, I ended up renting a film about pastry pricing in the West Indies, called ‘Pie Rates of the Caribbean’” was posted on Twitter on February 6, 2010.
   
“Pie rates of Penn’s aunts” is a similar pirate pun.
   
Other Pirates of the Caribbean jokes include “I sell pies from my car. $2 for apple, $3 for pumpkin. These are the pie rates of the car I be in,” “My yoga instructor is from Jamaica. She teaches Pilates of the Caribbean” and “What do you call glass cookware from Jamaica?”/“Pyrex of the Caribbean.”
     
     
Wikipedia: Pirates of the Caribbean (film series)
Pirates of the Caribbean is a series of American fantasy swashbuckler films produced by Jerry Bruckheimer and based on Walt Disney’s theme park ride of the same name.
(...)
The film series started in 2003 with Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl, which received positive reviews from critics and grossed US$654 million worldwide. After the first film’s success, Walt Disney Pictures revealed that a trilogy was in the works.
         
Twitter
John Ashton‏
@ickledot
Pie rates of the Caribbean.  Rubbish.  No pies.
2:08 PM - 27 Dec 2008
 
Twitter
Fanton‏
@FantonEsquire
Due to a mix-up at Blockbusters, I ended up renting a film about pastry pricing in the West Indies, called ‘Pie Rates of the Caribbean’.
9:40 AM - 6 Feb 2010
 
Twitter
Tim Hall‏
@scalawine
#meatmovies Pie Rates of the Caribbean
2:27 PM - 15 Feb 2010
 
Twitter
Lee‏
@leegoettl
Why would anyone be interested in the pie rates of the caribbean? isn’t pie about the same price?
3:08 PM - 29 Oct 2010
 
Reddit—Jokes
In Jamaica
submitted July 1, 2017 by Tiroler-Quelle
In Jamaica you can get a steak and kidney pie for £1.75, a chicken and mushroom pie for £1.60 and an apple pie for £2.15. In St Kitts and Nevis a steak and kidney pie will cost you £2, a chicken pie (without mushrooms) is £1.70 and a cherry pie can be yours for £1.95. In Trinidad and Tobago, that steak and kidney pie comes in at £2.50, but you can two for £3.50, while the chicken and mushroom pie is £2.25, or two for £3.25. They also offer meat and potato pie for £2, or two for £3. Their apple pies and cherry pies are often sold for £2.75, or two (any combination) for £4.75. Those are the Pie Rates of the Caribbean
 
Me.Me
PIE RATES OF THE CARIBBEAN IN JAMAICA YOU CAN GET A STEAK AND KIDNEY PIE FOR $175 A CHICKEN AND MUSHROOM PIE FOR $160 AND AN APPLE PIE FOR $215 IN ST KITTS AND NEVIS A STEAK AND KIDNEY PIE WILL COST YOU $2 A CHICKEN PIE WITHOUT MUSHROOMS IS $170 AND A CHERRY PIE CAN BE YOURS FOR $195 IN TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO THAT STEAK AND KIDNEY PIE COMES IN AT $250 BUT YOU CAN GET TWO FOR $350 WHILE THE CHICKEN AND MUSHROOM PIE IS $225 OR TWO FOR $325 THEY ALSO OFFER MEAT AND POTATO PIE FOR $2 OR TWO FOR $3 THEIR APPLE PIES AND CHERRY PIES ARE OFTEN SOLD FOR $275 OR TWO ANY COMBINATION FOR $475 THOSE ARE THE PIE RATES OF THE CARIBBEAN UNKNOWN PUNSTER @2017 PIE RATES OF THE CARIBBEAN #UNKNOWN_PUNSTER MEME
APPLE MEMES CHICKEN JAMAICA POTATO APPLE PIE 🤖 PIE CAN MUSHROOM CARIBBEAN TRINIDAD KIDNEY UNKNOWN MUSHROOMS TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO ST KITTS MEAT WILL POTATOES THEY YOU COMBINATION NEVIS FOR GET POTATOE STEAK THOSE POTATOS THEIR YOURS MEAT AND POTATOES TWO MEATS MEATE POTATOING AND THAT BUT SOLD THE CHERRY COSTED WITHOUT WHILE CHERRY PIE COMES ARE SOLDES
FOUND @ 2 LIKES ON 2017-07-04 19:27:58 BY ME.ME
SOURCE: FACEBOOK
 
10 July 2017, The Mercury (Durban, South Africa), “It’s your dream European holiday,” pg. 20:
In Jamaica you can get a steak and kidney pie for �1.75 (R26.74), a chicken and mushroom pie for �1.60 and an apple pie for �2.15.
 
In St Kitts and Nevis a steak and kidney pie will cost you �2, a chicken pie (without mushrooms) is �1.70 and a cherry pie can be yours for �1.95.
 
In Trinidad, Barbados, Tobago and Dominica that steak and kidney pie comes in at �2.50, but you can get two for �3.50, while the chicken and mushroom pie is �2.25, or two for�3.25.
 
They also offer meat and potato pie for �2, or two for �3. Their apple pies and cherry pies are often sold for �2.75, or two (any combination) for �4.75.
 
Those are the Pie Rates of the Caribbean.
 
Twitter
Col‏
@Bigshirtlesscol
Jamaica - Steak: $1.75
St Kitts   - Mince: $1.50
Trinidad - Apple: $2.00
Pie rates of the Caribbean.
3:41 PM - 10 Jul 2017 from North East, England
   
BuzzFeed
24 Times Britain Had The Funniest Tweets About Food
“I pay entry in clubs to stand on the dance floor and think about what I’m getting from Maccies on the way home.”
Posted on September 4, 2017, at 9:57 a.m.
Jamie Jones
BuzzFeed Staff
(...)
15.
Terry Burgoyne @terryburgoyne96
In Trinidad and Tobago it will cost you £2.50 for a steak pie, in Jamaica it will cost you £3.00. These are the pie rates of the Caribbean
9:58 AM - Aug 18, 2017
 
Twitter
Shit Jokes‏
@ShitJokes
In Aruba it will cost you £2.00 for a steak pie, in Jamaica it will cost you £2.50.
These are pie rates of the Caribbean
#talklikeapirateday
5:27 AM - 19 Sep 2017