A plaque remaining from the Big Apple Night Club at West 135th Street and Seventh Avenue in Harlem.

Above, a 1934 plaque from the Big Apple Night Club at West 135th Street and Seventh Avenue in Harlem. Discarded as trash in 2006.

Recent entries:
“Bread crumbs are just really small croutons” (4/19)
Entry forthcoming—B.P. (4/19)
“What kind of phone makes music?"/"A saxophone.” (4/19)
“What kind of phone makes music?"/"A saxophone.” (4/19)
“Croutons are just big bread crumbs” (4/19)
More new entries...

A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z


Entry from January 13, 2018
“What is a pirate’s favorite drink?"/"Hi-C.”

The fruit juice-flavored drink Hi-C sounds like “high sea.” “Q: What do pirate kids drink to prevent scurvy? A: High Sea” was posted on Twitter on September 19, 2008. “Whats a pirates favorite fruit drink? Hi-C’s” was posted on Twitter on February 23, 2010.

A riddle was posted on Reddit—Jokes on October 10, 2014:

Q: What is a pirate’s favorite drink?
A: The HI-C!


“What is a pirate’s favorite drink?” has also been given many other answers.


Wikipedia: Hi-C
Hi-C is a fruit juice-flavored drink made by Minute Maid division of The Coca-Cola Company. It was created by Niles Foster in 1946 and released in 1947. The sole original flavor was orange.

Twitter
John Uhri‏
@y0mbo
Q: What do pirate kids drink to prevent scurvy? A: High Sea. http://tinyurl.com/4x3jl2
11:01 AM - 19 Sep 2008

Twitter
Raymon Salceda Jr‏
@Rayjay2
What’s a Pirate’s favorite drink? ARRRRRRRange juice. Did you see the latest Pirate movie? I heard it was rated ARRRRRRRRRR.
6:31 PM - 19 Sep 2009

Twitter
Brian Rechenmacher‏
@Brian_Rex
Whats a pirates favorite fruit drink? Hi-C’s.
6:44 AM - 23 Feb 2010

Twitter
The Boiler Room‏
@BoilerRoomPDX
Q. What’s a pirate’s favorite drink?
A. Pee bee argh!
Come get some! Kj Bri, @FixedNotFree and Vanessa will take good care of you.
11:14 PM - 3 May 2012

Twitter
#TrueHogsClub‏
@Sourdough87
What’s a pirate’s favorite drink? Arrrrrgh-nold Palmers’
4:07 AM - 1 Jun 2012

Twitter
Bob Malkowski‏
@RobertMalkowski
What’s a pirate’s favorite drink? Aarrrrrrr-C Cola! #talklikeapirateday
6:29 AM - 19 Sep 2012

Twitter
CAIS BoardingSchools‏
@CAISboarding
Replying to @ourkidsnet
@ourkidsnet What’s a pirate’s favourite drink? Arrrr - C Cola #talklikeapirate
10:59 AM - 19 Sep 2012

Twitter
Buddhapuss Ink‏
@Buddhapuss
Talk Like a Pirate Day - What is a pirate’s favorite drink?
MARRRRRRRRRtinis
2:21 PM - 19 Sep 2012

Twitter
Bro Strider‏
@ManStrider
What’s a pirates favorite soft drink? HI-C!  #hilarious #puns #striderlife #funny
9:35 PM - 20 Apr 2013

Reddit—Jokes
What is a pirate’s favorite drink?
submitted October 10, 2014 by rtg35
The HI-C!
(punchline must be said in proper pirate voice)
(this is what I do when bored at work not even ashamed)

Twitter
most palone‏
@qrwhitt
What’s a pirate’s favorite drink?
Hi-C Admit it, you laughed, you’re welcome, good night.
11:18 PM - 22 Jan 2015

Twitter
Dan Cabrera‏
@Dan_Cab
Q: What’s a pirate’s favorite drink?
A: High-Sea (Hi-C)
#jokes #pirates
12:22 PM - 29 Jul 2015

Twitter
Lost in Transition‏
@MystryListener
Bad Joke of the Day:
What is a Pirate’s favorite drink?
High-Sea.
#BJoftheDay
12:11 PM - 28 Oct 2015

Twitter
Dave Baxley‏
@DaveBaxley
So what’s a Pirate’s favorite drink (besides Rum)? (Hi-C!) smile
8:20 PM - 22 Jun 2016

Reddit—Jokes
What’s a pirates favorite thing to drink?
submitted May 8, 2017 by ViCarly
Hi-C’s.

Reddit—Dad Jokes
What is a pirates favorite drink? (self.dadjokes)
submitted January 14, 2018 by DatFather
High Sea
COMMENTS
EasyGmoney
Whst is a pirates favorite letter? You would think Rrrr, but his first love is the C

Posted by Barry Popik
New York CityFood/Drink • Saturday, January 13, 2018 • Permalink